StubHub's Sales Falter After Eliminating Hidden Fees

StubHub's effort to please customers by eliminating hidden fees might have backfired. The online marketplace, owned by eBay

, switched to an “all-in” pricing scheme earlier this year. Hidden fees are the biggest everyday annoyance for Americans, according to

, so StubHub's new approach includes service charges and delivery fees in the initial prices listed for tickets. But the prices seem more expensive with the total cost presented upfront, and StubHub sales have fallen, the

. Some ticket brokers say sales have fallen by 15 to 50 percent since the pricing change. Although StubHub's prices may seem more expensive initially, hidden fees on other websites spike up the prices at checkout. A floor seat general admission ticket to the Lady Gaga concert at the Joe Louis Arena in Detroit this May is listed as $133.66 on

, $117 on

(plus $23.40 service charge and $15.00 delivery fee = $155.40), and $114 on

(plus $28.30 service charge and $14.95 delivery fee = $157.25). A Great Place to Sit president Rick Schefter said he has heard the pricing model has hurt the StubHub's sales. “Our sales are down with stubhub, and they are up in other areas,” he said. But, he said, another big factor is how the tickets are delivered. StubHub used to have a monopoly on the instant delivery mechanism. “That mechanism, which is a huge consumer driver, is now available on competitor sites,”he said, “and I see that taking a huge bite out of StubHubs sales.”

StubHub isn't the first company to take this kind of approach. Ticketmaster, a subsidiary of Live Nation

, did something similar a few years ago. Then-CEO Nathan Hubbard announced via Ticketmaster

that the company would present a new way of pricing and fees, where a customer can hover over a ticket price and see how the number shown is the total of the actual ticket price plus the service charge. “We get it – you don't like service fees. You don't like them mostly because you don't understand what the heck they are for,” the blog says. But Ticketmaster still manages to tack on a $4 processing fee at the end of the order, in addition to the delivery fee.

Marketing for the new pricing strategy lacked a press release or public announcement. The company informed its customers of its all-in pricing via

sent out in late January. “On StubHub, you'll see the final price right when you hit the site. Nothing more will be added to your cost. Not even delivery charges,” the email said. “Interested in Justin Timberlake tickets that you see listed for $100? Well, $100 is all you'll pay. On other sites, that same ticket might be listed for $88, but will cost you $104 when it's all said and done.” StubHub could benefit from educating its customers about how the higher prices reflect the elimination of hidden fees, Shefter said. “Any large company like that certainly has the wherewithal to do that kind of campaign,”he said. AllShows.com CEO Jason Berger told Benzinga he expects the initial drop in sales from the pricing change will subside when customers understand the all-in pricing model. “Eventually, I believe it will be more prevalent in the marketplace and provide consumers a better understanding of the prices they are being charged,” he said.